.
Misa Mi1, Lin Wu, AHIP2, Yingting Zhang, AHIP3, Wendy Wu4
doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.5195/jmla.2022.1368
Volume 110, Number 2: 247-252
Received 07 2021: Accepted 09 2021
ABSTRACT
Over the past ten years, there has been a growing interest in integrating arts and humanities in medicine to increase learners' empathy and resilience; improve personal well-being, communication, and observational skills; enhance self-reflection; and promote professionalism. These desired skills and qualities are becoming increasingly important for the physicians of tomorrow. Parallel to curricular interventions of integrating arts and humanities to medical education, there has been an increasing research interest in investigating the impact of such interventions on medical students with respect to improving and sustaining students' empathy as they progress in their medical education and develop their professional identity. Research has yielded interesting findings on the types and effect of the interventions in the medical curriculum. The Association of the American Medical Colleges (AAMC), recognizing the unique and unrealized role of arts and humanities in preparing and equipping physicians for twenty-first-century challenges, proposed seven recommendations for advancing arts and humanities integration into medical education to improve the education, practice, and well-being of physicians and physician learners across the spectrum of medical education. Institutional initiatives of arts and humanities integration in the medical curriculum in response to the AAMC's recommendations afford health sciences librarians expansive opportunities and a new landscape of playing an important role in these initiatives. With their diverse educational background in arts, humanities, social sciences, and many other disciplines and fields, health sciences librarians are poised for meaningful contributions to their institutional goals in developing a humanistic, compassionate workforce of future physicians.
Keywords: arts; humanities; health sciences library; undergraduate medical education; medical education; health sciences librarians.
Human beings use the arts as the vehicles to express the meanings of their lives [1]. Medical humanities can promote a depth of human and humane understanding, knowledge, and experience [2]. The humanities force reflective thinking and contemplation skills that are essential to thoughtful decision-making and to personal wellness. Beyond that, in Danielle Ofri's opinion, the humanities add “a dose of joy and beauty” to an arduous training process that is notoriously barren in these areas. Well integrated into the training, the humanities can be the kernel of transforming medical knowledge into clinical wisdom [3]. John Gillies states that “arts and humanities approaches are intrinsic to society's understanding of medicine” [4]. In treating and caring for sick and often distressed patients, physicians repeatedly confront fundamental questions about the meaning and sanctity of life and the problem of suffering [5], and they grapple with uncertainty and ambiguity in clinical decision-making. Gillie Bolton believes that “a sound grounding in the arts and humanities can enable an effectively critical, humane, and ethical response” [5].
Evidence-based medicine (a systematic approach to medicine) is to use the current best available evidence from patient-focused clinical research to inform clinical decision-making in the care of individual patients. However, a clinician's clinical judgment, expertise, experience, and the patient's values and preferences are equally important in the process of clinical decision-making [6]. Furthermore, in patient encounters, clinicians bring their own perspectives or personal experiences; individual patients bring their afflicted bodies or troubled minds. Howard Brody expressed his sentiment by saying, “Often more than the body or mind is broken: patients' understanding of themselves and the certainty of their lives is often also disrupted and disturbed” [7]. Apart from that, patients' hearts could be troubled and shattered. The use of clinical evidence is for treating and curing the damaged and afflicted body in the physical sense, but the minds and emotions associated with the brokenness have to be examined and attended to through incorporating the lens of the humanistic view with compassion and empathy. Attention to the patient's role in both evidence-based medicine and humanistic medicine could help create a holism in medicine where the clinician and the patient can “co-construct a curative and healing narrative that involves medical and healthcare interventions, and mental and emotional understandings, which can help the patient constructively rebuild their life, or prepare for death” [7].
How can medical educators use arts and humanities (AH) as a means or vehicle to instill a humanistic view of medicine in learners across the spectrum of medical education? How can medical educators help mitigate learners' stress and burnout in face of the many challenges in completing medical school?
The Liaison Committee on Medical Education establishes standards for accreditation of medical education programs leading to the MD degree in the United States and Canada. Among all the standards, Standard 10 is related to medical student selection, assignment, and progress. It states:
Through its requirements for admission, a medical school encourages potential applicants to the medical education program to acquire a broad undergraduate education that includes the study of the humanities, natural sciences, and social sciences, and confines its specific premedical course requirements to those deemed essential preparation for successful completion of its medical curriculum [8].
The Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) has instigated efforts in strengthening the medical school applicant selection by developing fifteen core competencies for entering students. These core competencies are used to form selection and admission criteria for medical school applicants. To be successful, applicants must demonstrate certain skills, knowledge, and abilities in areas such as social skills, cultural competence, resilience and adaptability, oral and written communication, and human behavior [9]. AAMC also took its stand on the role of arts and humanities in undergraduate medical education by stating, “By integrating arts and humanities throughout medical education, trainees and physicians can learn to be better observers and interpreters; and build empathy, communication and teamwork skills, and more” [10]. Clearly, AAMC recognized the unique and unrealized role of AH in preparing and equipping physicians for twenty-first-century challenges in contributing to optimal health care outcomes for patients and communities. The organization proposed seven recommendations for advancing AH integration into medical education to improve the education, practice, and well-being of physicians and physician learners across the spectrum of medical education [10]. The recommendations focus on: (1) practicing medicine as an art as well as a science to develop a deep understanding of the human conditions in trainees and physicans; (2) creating more effective AH integrated models for competency-based teaching and learning in medicine; (3) enhancing the research and evaluation of AH integrated courses and programs; (4) designing AH integrated approaches to enhancing trainee and physican well-being; (5) increasing interdisciplinary or multidisciplinary collaboration among scholars and learners and patients; (6) providing professional development offerings on designing and using AH integrated models in medical education; and (7) investigating the effectiveness of AH integrated educational practice and recognizing the value of scholarship in such research endeavors in academic promotion and tenure process [10]. Clearly, these seven recommendations point to strong implications for medical educators and researchers as well as health sciences libraries.
Over the past decade, there has been a growing interest in integrating AH into health profession educational programs to increase learners' empathy and resilience; improve personal well-being, communication, and observational skills; enhance self-reflection; and promote professionalism. These skills and qualities are becoming increasingly important for the physicians of tomorrow. According to the AAMC Curriculum Inventory, during the year of 2015–2016, humanities education was required in 119 medical schools. While there has been a growth in teaching humanities in the medical curriculum, there has been a lack for a “deep, sustained, foundational, across-the-board incorporation into all medical schools” [11].
Parallel to AH interventions in the medical curriculum, there has been an increasing research interest in investigating the impact of AH interventions on medical students with respect to improving and sustaining their empathy, and developing their communication, observational, and other important skills as they progress in their education and form their professional identity. Previous research has yielded promising findings on the efficacy of AH interventions in the medical curriculum.
We conducted a comprehensive review of the literature to find out how AH was integrated in medical education and what impact the integration had on students during the critical years of their identity formation in medical school. The literature review reveals that different types of AH intervention were developed and implemented in the medical curriculum. Artwork was most used in interventions, followed by film, theater or drama, humor, patients' stories, and comic strips. The artwork used in the interventions came from various sources, including a gallery or museum [12–14], patients with chronic mental illness [15], medical students participating in research studies [16–18], and patients in collaboration with students [19]. The artwork was used as a vehicle to present a wide array of learning experiences to examine the impact of artistic creativity on life, students' understanding of palliative care [12], observational skills [13, 14, 20], level of empathy [17, 20, 21], and communications skills with an attitude toward older adults [19] or chronically ill older patients [18].
Another way of embedding AH into the curriculum was using movies to address topics of professionalism, mental illness, empathy, patient encounters, bias toward patients with mental illness, and psychological stress. Examples of these interventions include students watching a movie with still and moving images with music but stripped of dialogue [22]; students involved in movie screening, critiquing, analyzing, and comparing and contrasting the representation of mental illness, psychiatry, or psychiatrists [23]; students watching a movie that ended with interviews with former medical students and body donors in the movie [24]; and students watching video clips from movies and discussing patient encounters [25].
Theater or drama techniques were applied in interventions to teach students about breaking bad news or delivering death notification [26, 27], to develop positive professional qualities and interpersonal skills [28], and to sustain or enhance empathy [29]. Other AH interventions attempted to impart to students fundamental skills for a humanistic physician by using humor [30], patients' stories [31], or comic strips [32].
AH interventions were implemented throughout medical education, but more were found in the curricula of the first year or clinical years. Reported outcomes were primarily in seven categories: (1) enhanced compassion or empathy, (2) improved communication skills, (3) enhanced professionalism or professional identity, (4) improved observational skills, (5) increased humanistic view, (6) reduced burnout/stress, and (7) enhanced physician-patient relations. The outcome data seem promising and thus point to the importance and value of AH integration and resulted outcomes in medical and other health profession educational programs in developing a future workforce of humanistic health care providers.
Many health sciences libraries and librarians have been successful in exerting influence on many institution-wide initiatives and programs in various areas, such as ongoing support for clinical or biomedical research, teaching evidence-based medicine, forging partnerships with faculty in teaching students, and educating or assisting researchers in conducting systematic reviews. Institutional initiatives in AH integration in medical education in response to the AAMC's recommendations afford health sciences librarians a new landscape of opportunities for participating in these initiatives. With their rich and diverse backgrounds, expertise in information management, and organizational skills, coupled with their ability to reach out to communities and work with multidisciplinary teams, health sciences librarians are well positioned to contribute to their institutional goals in developing humanistic and compassionate physicians. It is time for librarians to leverage their multifaceted role and skill sets to lead or participate in initiatives and efforts in integrating arts and humanities into the teaching and learning practices at their home institutions.
The literature review gave us the lay of the land and shed light on multiple approaches to AH integration and its impact on medical students. The growing interest in and attention to the integration in medicine, investigating its impact fueled by the AAMC initiative for the FRAHME (the Fundamental Role of the Arts and Humanities in Medical Education), and the seven recommendations for integrative arts and humanities curricula implicate great potential for health sciences librarians in innovating and expanding their role to exert an impact in health profession educational programs. What follows are a few recommendations for health sciences librarians who desire to expand their roles, innovate their library services and programs, and build communities and forge multidisciplinary collaboration, interaction, and partnerships with different groups of constituents at their home institution.
In this digital age, with increasing online learning and remote access to teaching and learning resources, health sciences libraries are propelled to take innovative and creative approaches to reaching out to their constituents and wider communities. The AH integration affords health sciences libraries great opportunities for expanding their endeavors to advance health humanities scholarship, education, and practices through multidisciplinary methods focusing on the intersection of arts, humanities, culture, health, illness, and health care.
Health sciences librarians have been on the front line of teaching evidence-based medicine and facilitating use of and access to evidence-based resources. The scientific research evidence from evidence-based resources informs clinicians' decision-making on the care for patients, treating and curing the physical suffering. However, the distressed inner minds and turbulent emotions associated with the shattered, troubled hearts resulting from the damaged body may need to be attended with the lens of the humanistic, holistic view with compassion and empathy. The AH integration into health profession educational programs can well serve as an intervention to instill the humanistic, holistic view in students who will be entrusted to care for patients with compassion and empathy. The increased interest in integrating AH in medicine to develop well-rounded health care providers against the backdrop of the current pandemic provides a fertile ground for health sciences librarians to be creative and innovative in practicing health sciences librarianship. Librarians' involvement in AH interventions would add to their arsenal of skill sets and expertise. These skills would be indispensable to strategic goals of molding and transforming health profession students into future health care providers who contribute to optimal patient care and outcomes. Librarians' involvement in the AH integration may inject a dose of joy and beauty into the learners' academic lives and librarians' professional lives alike.
1. Calman K, Downie R. Why arts courses for medical curricula. Lancet. 1996;347(9014):1499–500. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0140-6736(96)90665-0.
2. Downie RS. Medical humanities: a vision and some cautionary notes. Med Humanit. 2003;29(1):37–38. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/mh.29.1.37.
3. Ofri D. Medical humanities: the Rx for uncertainty? Acad Med. 2017;92(12):1657–8. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/ACM.0000000000001983.
4. Gillies J. Compassion, medical humanities and medical education. Educ Prim Care. 2018;29(2):68–70. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14739879.2018.1427004.
5. Bolton G. Medicine, the arts, and the humanities. Lancet. 2003;362(9378):93–94. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(03)13894-9.
6. Evidence-based medicine [Internet]. National Cancer Institute [cited 5 April 2021]. <https://www.cancer.gov/publications/dictionaries/cancer-terms/def/evidence-based-medicine>.
7. Brody H. Stories of sickness. 2nd ed. New York: Oxford University Press; 2003.
8. Liaison Committee on Medical Education (LCME). Functions and structure of a medical school: standards for accreditation of medical education programs leading to the MD degree [Internet]. Association of American Medical Colleges and American Medical Association; 2019 [cited 5 June 2021]. <https://lcme.org/publications/>.
9. Association of American Medical Colleges. The core competencies for entering medical students [Internet]. Washington, DC: Association of American Medical Colleges [cited 10 June 2021]. <https://www.aamc.org/services/admissions-lifecycle/competencies-entering-medical-students>.
10. Howley L, Gaufberg E, King B. The fundamental role of arts and humanities in medical education [Internet]. Chicago, IL: Association of American Medical Colleges; 2020 [cited 29 March 2021]. <https://www.aamc.org/what-we-do/mission-areas/medical-education/frahme>.
11. Mann S. Focusing on arts, humanities to develop well-rounded physicians [Internet]. Chicago, IL: Association of American Medical Colleges; 2017 [cited 24 September 2019]. <https://www.aamc.org/news-insights/focusing-arts-humanities-develop-well-rounded-physicians>.
12. Centeno C, Robinson C, Noguera-Tejedor A, Arantzamendi M, Echarri F, Pereira J. Palliative care and the arts: vehicles to introduce medical students to patient-centred
decision-making and the art of caring. BMC Medl Educ. 2017;17(1):257. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-017-1098-6.
13. He B, Prasad S, Higashi RT, Goff HW. The art of observation: a qualitative analysis of medical students' experiences. BMC Med Educ. 2019;19(1):234. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-019-1671-2.
14. Gurwin J, Revere KE, Niepold S, Bassett B, Mitchell R, Davidson S, DeLisser H, Binenbaum G. A randomized controlled study of art observation training to improve medical student
ophthalmology skills. Ophthalmology. 2018;125(1):8–14. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ophtha.2017.06.031.
15. Cutler JL, Harding KJ, Hutner LA, Cortland C, Graham MJ. Reducing medical students' stigmatization of people with chronic mental illness: a
field intervention at the “living museum𠇍 state hospital art studio. Acad Psychiatry. 2012;36(3):191–6. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ap.10050081.
16. Cox SM, Brett-MacLean P, Courneya CA. "My turbinado sugar": art-making, well-being and professional identity in medical
education. Arts & Health. 2016;8(1):65–81. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/17533015.2015.1037318.
17. Potash J, Chen J. Art-mediated peer-to-peer learning of empathy. Clin Teach. 2014;11(5):327–31. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/tct.12157.
18. LoFaso VM, Breckman R, Capello CF, Demopoulos B, Adelman RD. Combining the creative arts and the house call to teach medical students about chronic
illness care. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2010;58(2):346–51. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1532-5415.2009.02686.x.
19. Kodadek LM, Bettendorf BA, Uihlein JA, Derse AR. The memory art project: medical students and older adults. Wis Med J. 2010;109(6):311–6.
20. Yang K, Lin C, Chang L. A program to interest medical students in Changhua, Taiwan in the incorporation of visual arts in medicine. Educ Health. 2011;24(3):1–10.
21. Jasani SK, Saks NS. Utilizing visual art to enhance the clinical observation skills of medical students. Med Teach. 2013;35(7):e1327–e31. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3109/0142159X.2013.770131.
22. Brand G, Wise S, Siddiqui ZS, Celenza A, Fatovich DM. Capturing the 'art' of emergency medicine: Does film foster reflection in medical
students? Emerg Med Australas. 2017;29(4):433–7. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/1742-6723.12752.
23. Datta V. Madness and the movies: an undergraduate module for medical students. Int Rev Psychiatry. 2009;21(3):261–6. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09540260902748001.
24. Iaconisi J, Hasselblatt F, Mayer B, Schoen M, Bockers TM, Bockers A. Effects of an educational film about body donors on students' empathy and anxiety
levels in gross anatomy. Anat Sci Educ. 2019;12(4):386–98. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/ase.1880.
25. Hojat M, Axelrod D, Spandorfer J, Mangione S. Enhancing and sustaining empathy in medical students. Med Teach. 2013;35(12):996–1001. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.3109/0142159X.2013.802300.
26. Skye EP, Wagenschutz H, Steiger JA, Kumagai AK. Use of interactive theater and role play to develop medical students' skills in breaking
bad news. J Cancer Educ. 2014;29(4):704–8. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s13187-014-0641-y.
27. Nordstrom A, Fjellman-Wiklund A, Grysell T. Drama as a pedagogical tool for practicing death notification-experiences from Swedish
medical students. BMC Med Educ. 2011;11:74. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/1472-6920-11-74.
28. Scott KM, Berlec S, Nash L, Hooker C, Dwyer P, Macneill P, River J, Ivory K. Grace under pressure: a drama-based approach to tackling mistreatment of medical students. Med Humanit. 2017;43(1):68–70. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/medhum-2016-011031.
29. Lim BT, Moriarty H, Huthwaite M. "Being-in-role": a teaching innovation to enhance empathic communication skills in
medical students. Med Teach. 2011;33(12):e663–e9. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.3109/0142159X.2011.611193.
30. Karnieli-Miller O, Michael K, Segal O, Steinberger A. Assessing an intervention focused on enhancing interpersonal communication skills
and humor: a multi-method quasi-experiential study among medical students. Health Communication. 2018;33(12):1560–72. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10410236.2017.1384347.
31. Jones EK, Kittendorf AL, Kumagai AK. Creative art and medical student development: a qualitative study. Med Educ. 2017;51(2):174–83. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/medu.13140.
32. Tsao P, Yu CH. “There's no billing code for empathy” - animated comics remind medical students of
empathy: a qualitative study. BMC Med Educ. 2016;16(1):204. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-016-0724-z.
Misa Mi, 1 mi@oakland.edu, Interim Director, Medical Library; Professor, Department of Foundational Medical Studies; Oakland University William Beaumont School of Medicine Medical Library, Rochester, MI
Lin Wu, AHIP, 2 lwu5@uthsc.edu, Assistant Director/Associate Professor, Research & Learning Services, Health Sciences Library, University of Tennessee Health Science Center, Memphis, TN
Yingting Zhang, AHIP, 3 yzhang@libraries.rutgers.edu, Research Services Librarian, RWJ Library of the Health Sciences; Adjunct Assistant Professor, Department of Medicine; Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey, New Brunswick, NJ
Wendy Wu, 4 wendy.wu@wayne.edu, Librarian IV, Shiffman Medical Library, Wayne State University; Detroit, MI
Copyright © 2022 Misa Mi, Lin Wu, Yingting Zhang, Wendy Wu
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Journal of the Medical Library Association, VOLUME 110, NUMBER 2, April 2022